The Open Access Movement in fragile balance

Report (2003) by Sandra Fauconnier about Darius Cuplinskas' talk at Copy the Rights!

Darius Cuplinskas was the first lecturer of the Copy the Rights! seminar at DEAF03. He gave a presentation that focused on the role of the Open Society Institute in the Open Access movement (a movement promoting free access to online scientific literature), and on the history of that movement itself. The Open Society Institute in Budapest, part of the Soros Foundations network, has been active in Eastern Europe and the Soviet Union during the past 10 years; currently the network is moving its activities to other developing parts of the world such as Southern and Western Africa, Latin America and others. Cuplinskas works for the Information Program of the OSI Hungary, which offers support in the field of information technology and helps, among others, Internet providers and libraries in setting up a good infrastructure. Through its contacts with research libraries in developing countries, the OSI has become involved in the Open Access Movement. In November 2001 it co-initiated the Budapest Open Access Initiative, which was backed up by a $3,000 grant by the Soros Foundation. Since then, nearly 3,000 research scientists have signed the Initiative, expressing their interest in making their research articles more openly available; furthermore, BOAI has supported and funded various Open Access-related activities.

Cuplinskas emphasized that the Open Access model - emerging from scientific publishing, which he called the oldest open source movement - has a lot of parallels with other domains and that a lot can be done within the current copyright system.

He then drew a brief history of scientific communication, which goes back to 1665 when the first print-based journal was published. It had five functions - registration of intellectual property of the authors; credentialling via refereeing and quality via peer review; "branding" of authors; dissemination; archiving - which remained largely unchanged for 300 years and founded a political order within scientific communication, with a constitutional tension of access versus quality, dissemination versus hierarchy. Scientific publishing was not quite profitable until after World War II, when Eugene Garfield invented "citation indexing", a system that makes it possible to rank journals according to the number of citations they receive. Thus, a very strong hierarchy emerges with a list of prestigious core journals (10% to 20% of all scientific journals). Soon, an alliance between scientists and publishers was forged, scientific publishing became big business, during the last 10 years prices of journals have risen 200% (!) and an oligopoly of only a handful of large-scale journal publishers came into being (Reed Elsevier, Kluwer, Springer, Wiley).

Next, Cuplinskas listed some important Open Access activities that react to this situation - lobbying groups and initiatives such as SPARC and the 2001 Public Library of Science (PLoS) petition, free online publishers such as BioMed Central (which works with author processing fees), important eprint repositories such as the huge and very successful, founded in 1991 by Paul Ginsparg, and the Open Archives interoperability initiative. Movements such as Open Access and Open Source depend on some important criteria: a commons, integration mechanisms with some hierarchy and a legal framework - these movements can't exist without copyright!

Finally, Cuplinskas stated that the present time is a crucial juncture for the Open Access movement; the following five years will decide whether this movement will obtain sufficient impact or die a silent death. High-quality back-end applications on top of open eprint archives and traditional journals will be crucial there; the "Faculty of 1000" project, where biologists recommend their favorite papers, is a good example of such an application.

Document Actions
Document Actions
Mailinglist: Subscribe to the English or Dutch version.

Follow usfacebook_16.png twitter_16.png youtube_16.png Favicon Vimeo googleplus
Related Items
Copy the Rights! Feb 26, 2003 12:00 PM

A seminar about intellectual property at DEAF03.

Sandra Fauconnier

Sandra Fauconnier (BE/NL) is a researcher and media archive expert.

Copyright and alternatives: an overview

An article by Sandra Fauconnier on open access, open content, open source software and copyright ...

Copyright and Digital Culture Mar 13, 2002 10:00 AM

An expert meeting on copyright, media culture, archiving and open source software.

Kingdom of Piracy

Kingdom of Piracy (K.O.P.) (2003) is an online workspace exploring the free sharing of digital ...


"Burnstation" (2003-) by Platoniq is a public space installation and action for a free audio ...


ETAWARE (2003) is a system for the enacting of timebased archives developed by Knowbotic Research ...

The Budapest Open Access Initiative

Manifesto of the The Budapest Open Access Initiative (2002)

DEAF03 Open Territories Feb 25, 2003 12:00 PM

The Open Territories program at DEAF03 offer a diverse public forum of debate and investigation ...

Tools & Creators Nov 28, 2003 02:00 PM

A workshop that examines the tools available for the creation of interactive and non-linear media, ...

V2_ Online Strategy

Presentation regarding V2_ online strategy for 2010-2011.

Connective Software, Open Code

A report on the Creative Kernel's workshop (DEAF00) by Sandra Fauconnier.

Media Knitting Feb 26, 2003 12:00 PM

A workshop at DEAF03 for artists, engineers, and designers working with software.

404 - Legal Protection Fault

Short report by Sandra Fauconnier about Jon Ippolito's talk on intellectual property and the ...

The Privacy Card

'Privacy Card' is a project by the German artist/activist duo FoeBuD, formed by Rena Tangens and ...


The research project V2_Jam (2002) investigates mixing media and mixing softwares.

more ...
Personal tools
Log in